Gear Guy Answers…..

From October 03, 2005 outdoor gear question: Can you recommend a daypack with good suspension?

My homage: I am a regular and long-time reader; I have made purchases based on your advice; I previously submitted questions regarding winter camping gear; I even read your book, A Season of Fire. Everything but drink the Kool-Aid! My quandary: I am six-foot-four with a long torso and am having trouble finding daypacks that fit. Do you have any recommendations for a medium- or high-volume daypack with a good suspension system?
— Jim Holland Patent, New York

You should make a pilgrimage to Port Townsend, Washington, young Jim, so you can learn at the foot of the Master. I will teach you many things gearly, what is right and what is wrong, what will work and what will not. All I ask in return is that… you weed a large portion of the yard that has gotten out of control; finish rebuilding and painting 18 storm windows that have to go back up before the weather gets too dicey; reinstall two Campy shifter-levers on my classic old Merckx bicycle; and re-lay the vapor barrier under the house. All minor jobs, but ones that must be done!

As for daypacks, well, I hear your pain. Most of them aren’t made to fit the taller and shorter minions on the bell curve. So look around for packs that come in a sufficient range of sizes to allow for a “tall.” One such pack is Arc’teryx’s Needle 45 ($225;, a good-sized (about 3,000 cubic inches), technical daypack that is available in a tall size to fit a back length (just below your neck to just above your butt) of 23 inches. Same for Osprey’s Eclipse 36+5 ($169;, another roomy daypack (2,400 cubic inches in the large size) with an excellent suspension. Mountainsmith’s Achilles ($170; is in the same fit range as the Osprey and Arc’teryx when you purchase the large size, and it’s a touch larger—about 3,200 cubic inches.

Of course, you’ll want to try some of these on in a store to see what works best. But I think with a little care you’ll find one that accommodates your lo-o-ng torso. Let me know what works!

I am rather a tall drink of H2O myself and found the Mountainsmith Approach II pack to be very comfortable. I purchased mine through Sierra Trading Post. I don’t believe it came in tall but fits a torso up to 22 inches. I really like the pack thus far. It is now available in Campmor.


Comments are closed.